Skip to main content
replaced http://puzzling.stackexchange.com/ with https://puzzling.stackexchange.com/
Source Link
  1. I don't have VTC privilege on this site yet, but, if I did, I would be inclined to leave It is related to a type of mathematics gameIt is related to a type of mathematics game closed because it is a mathematics problem and not a mathematics puzzle.  A question shouldn't be reopened just because the original close reason has been resolved; it should be reopened only if it is worthy to be open.
  2. Maybe this is an incorrect way of thinking, but: The question appears to have a unique solution (answer), and it has gotten that answer (twice).  It's not clear what purpose is served by opening the question to new answers.
  1. I don't have VTC privilege on this site yet, but, if I did, I would be inclined to leave It is related to a type of mathematics game closed because it is a mathematics problem and not a mathematics puzzle.  A question shouldn't be reopened just because the original close reason has been resolved; it should be reopened only if it is worthy to be open.
  2. Maybe this is an incorrect way of thinking, but: The question appears to have a unique solution (answer), and it has gotten that answer (twice).  It's not clear what purpose is served by opening the question to new answers.
  1. I don't have VTC privilege on this site yet, but, if I did, I would be inclined to leave It is related to a type of mathematics game closed because it is a mathematics problem and not a mathematics puzzle.  A question shouldn't be reopened just because the original close reason has been resolved; it should be reopened only if it is worthy to be open.
  2. Maybe this is an incorrect way of thinking, but: The question appears to have a unique solution (answer), and it has gotten that answer (twice).  It's not clear what purpose is served by opening the question to new answers.
Source Link
Peregrine Rook
  • 4.9k
  • 10
  • 11

  1. I don't have VTC privilege on this site yet, but, if I did, I would be inclined to leave It is related to a type of mathematics game closed because it is a mathematics problem and not a mathematics puzzle.  A question shouldn't be reopened just because the original close reason has been resolved; it should be reopened only if it is worthy to be open.
  2. Maybe this is an incorrect way of thinking, but: The question appears to have a unique solution (answer), and it has gotten that answer (twice).  It's not clear what purpose is served by opening the question to new answers.