Since this is a site for puzzling AND puzzle-related questions, might there be a tag (or an area) specifically for brainstorming how to refine a puzzle?
Say I have a question that is quite open ended and I have two possible solutions to the riddle or puzzle; or I'm thinking there might be a formula to describe all the solutions rather than a single solution. Would I need to wait until I can refine it down to its most complete form first, or could I post a question like this:
"I am the one who is obnoxious and hard to read. Cut off my head, two shall take its place. You won't find this in my pillow. Take the other half of this toy."
I may believe that "2up Yo" is a perfect solution to my puzzle (yes I know it's a stupid example but work with me), but while watching people trying to stumble through my terrible clues they might discover some much more interesting ways to interpret my clues. They're probably not going to find a secret treasure in the Washington Monument off of that drivel, but odds are, they'd find something much more interesting than my very terrible solution.
Supposing that I know someone out there's going to find a better answer to my riddle than what I had in mind, might it be appropriate to tag my puzzle as such so that all puzzlers walk into the thread knowing ahead of time that it's perfectly acceptable to do something crazy like build a giant crane, or look away from the mountain, or chop up the rope into powder, or rope up a couple of sea turtles...
Normally these kinds of puzzles get put on hold because they're too vague and there's not one clear solution, but I think if this site is going to be a resource for puzzlers in general, these kinds of puzzles are going to be very helpful when puzzlers move on to creating new puzzles.