When I join a site on Stack Exchange network, the first thing I do is to check the tour page - specifically the "Get answers to practical, detailed questions" paragraph which lists what questions are and are not allowed on the particular sub-site.
That paragraph on Puzzling's tour unfortunately diverges dramatically the way this site is used. It says it is for
Specific questions about the creation and solving of puzzles, but every single question that I've seen on "Newest Questions" and SE-wide "Most Popular" was just a straight-up puzzle with answers being straight-up solutions. No analysis, no discussion on the craft.
It ought to be fixed.
This thread is for brainstorming a sleek, clean and informative replacement.