10
$\begingroup$

Stemming from a comment I left on an answer to this question:

You say the hint was a red herring. So are hints that aren't hints allowed? I guess they would be, just curious if it was ever brought up on meta.

I didn't see any meta posts about this already, so I thought I would bring it up myself.

Are hints that are actually not hints allowed?


Note: Whether or not the question I linked has a misleading hint isn't the purpose of this post. As pointed out in the comment below mine, it very well actually be a hint that the answerer didn't understand.

$\endgroup$
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ (For the record, the hint was a misleading one) $\endgroup$ – Fabich May 26 '16 at 8:52
18
$\begingroup$

I cannot address this question without lifting a quote from The Joys Of Yiddish

The first riddle I ever heard, one familiar to almost every Jewish child, was propounded to me by my father:
"What is it that hangs on the wall, is green, wet -- and whistles?"
I knit my brow and thought and thought, and in final perplexity gave up.
"A herring," said my father.
"A herring," I echoed. "A herring doesn't hang on the wall!"
"So hang it there."
"But a herring isn't green!" I protested.
"Paint it."
"But a herring isn't wet."
"If it's just painted it's still wet."
"But -- " I sputtered, summoning all my outrage, "-- a herring doesn't whistle!!"
"Right, " smiled my father. "I just put that in to make it hard."

By which I mean to say: "no".

I think there are allowable ways to mislead the reader. Taking the puzzle you link to merely as an example, I would say that putting the markings on a ring belonging to Gollum, and having them glow like the script on the One Ring in LOTR are absolutely fair play. The markings look to me more like Dwarven runes so I would also call it fair to say he pulled it from the finger of a dead Dwarf lord. I would even call it fair (but beyond what I personally would do) to add a sentence saying: "For those interested in the various scripts of Middle Earth see..." and provide links. Better would be to modify the last line of the problem statement to be:

he can't wait to go back home to use an elvish dictionary.

I would call that fair but inartistic. Ideally, you want to lead the reader gently astray and this feels more like pushing him off the path.

A misleading hint comes in a different class. I believe that when you write "Hint:" and put in a spoiler tag you are giving meta information about the puzzle. It is part of the puzzle statement or the conditions for solving it. You can make your hints tricky, I myself have been accused of being "sly", or you can give hints that only make sense after the puzzle has been solved. It is not fair to directly say that something has bearing on the solution when it doesn't. I believe it is the same principle as adding misleading tags.

I think the appropriate response is a downvote and a comment explaining why. That's my take on it.

$\endgroup$
  • $\begingroup$ Yes, I do agree. $\endgroup$ – Insane May 27 '16 at 10:42
  • $\begingroup$ +1. Great answer. $\endgroup$ – KeyboardWielder May 28 '16 at 7:54
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ Ok, sorry for this misleading hint. I won't do it again ;) $\endgroup$ – Fabich May 29 '16 at 15:29
  • 3
    $\begingroup$ @Lordofdark we're all trying to figure this out as we go. No worries. $\endgroup$ – Hugh Meyers May 29 '16 at 16:51
  • $\begingroup$ How is "and whistles" more like "leading the reader gently astray" than "pushing him off the path"? Feels a lot like pushing to me. $\endgroup$ – Ian MacDonald Jun 6 '16 at 19:19
  • 1
    $\begingroup$ @IanMacDonald The herring riddle was meant to be an example of an unfair riddle. $\endgroup$ – Hugh Meyers Jun 6 '16 at 19:37
  • $\begingroup$ What about the "Don't Worry Be Happy" fish? They whistle :P $\endgroup$ – dcfyj Jun 7 '16 at 13:57

You must log in to answer this question.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged .