This is a follow-up to Why do we have review audits?, in which I commented on the weirdness of having review audits on Puzzling when they're otherwise reserved for the largest SE sites. In that post, I enquired as to why they were introduced in the first place, and Emrakul♦ said:
We had enabled audits as an experiment waaaaay back in beta in response to a long, long string of terrible reviews and a handful of review bans. It was a test [...]
if you guys want it disabled, I'm not opposed. It just comes down to whether it annoys, and how much.
This post is intended to discuss that issue: whether review audits on Puzzling are actually doing any good, or whether they're obsolete (or were unnecessary in the first place) and should be abolished.
Should we continue having review audits here?
If so, why? If not, why not?