Although the tittle suggests this is a duplicate, I feel that this is an unanswered question. (because this is assuming only one party, and this is a different problem.)

I've come across a few puzzles (specifically riddles with multiple clues) that one person answers correctly but the clues wrong, or other way around.

Then later, another user answers the clues correctly, but based off of the first person's semi correct answer.

In this case who would be more appropriate to accept?



Browse other questions tagged .